 |
|
||||
|
 |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
2008 Fall Season
Top Chef Season Five
75
Summer Heights High
67
Whale Wars
71
Law & Order Season 19
74
Brotherhood Season Three
75
|
Sherlock Holmes And The Case Of The Silk Stocking
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
 |
|
||||||||||||
Starring Rupert Everett, Ian Hart, Helen McCrory, Neil Dudgeon, Jonathan Hyde, Eleanor David, Julian Wadham, and Penny Downie
This Masterpiece Theatre presentation stars Rupert Everett as the famed sleuth who investigates the murder of a young woman.
| GENRE(S): | Drama, Mystery & Thriller |
| FIRST AIR DATE: | October 23, 2005 |
All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...
The average user rating for this tv show is 6.1 (out of 10) based on 12 User Votes
Note: User votes are NOT included in the Metascore calculation.
Armond P gave it a2:
As a standalone drama, this show could perhaps be of interest to a viewer not acquainted with Holmes as portrayed in the Canon. However as a Holmes pastiche dramatization, this offering leaves a very vapid taste in one's mouth.
Mary C gave it a9:
Yes, it does differ from the "old" very stero-type Sherlock / Dr. Watson characters ... I loved it. No more cold, almost heartless Sherlock ... No more completely baffled Dr. Watson and oh how wonderful to have a strong women character, one that can stand up to and even recieve respect from the great mind of Sherlock. Not to mention the thriller aspect added to the story. All I can say is MORE PLEASE ....
Robert S gave it a5:
This was by far the worst of Sherlock Holmes on PBS. I loved Jeremy Brett's Holmes. Rupert Everett is not up to that level nor is the story up to that level.
Stella M gave it a9:
Everett makes a sexy Holmes!
Abigail H gave it an8:
Rupert Everett deserves acclaim and award nominations for his imperious but sad take on the Sherlock Holmes. character. From the first scene, I was mesmerized by the outstanding acting, the moody production and the spine tingling dramatic sequences. I hope Masterpiece Theater bring back the principal actors for more Sherlock Holmes movies.
Ronald G gave it a4:
I almost turned it off in the first half-hour, since I was definitely put-off by the dark turn to Holmes' character and his relationship with Watson. There was none of the wry humor or affectionate teasing that humanized Brett's Holmes. Watson, too, is revamped for the 21st-century audience and is hardly recognizable as Doyle's echt-Edwardian ex-military man whose relative stiffness so contrasted with Holmes' worldliness and willingness to bend the rules. I couldn't believe his indulgent smile as his fiancee rattled off all the sexual perversions. Even Holmes was shocked. Finally, I agree with the critics who found the criminal unworthy of the encounter with Holmes. There is some cleverness in the device by which the perpetrator hides his identity, but ultimately this is just a sick, obsessive with a perversion out of control, not a great criminal mind or careful, clever fiend.
J Graves gave it an8:
I loved Holmes qua zen master of doom. The heroin twist was a little strange because coke injections would've helped keep Holmes alive and kicking through a week-long case much better. Although I like the decadent/deviant quality that heroin use provides Everett's Holmes...blurring the lines between good and evil and all of that, pretty successfully.
 |
Return to top of page |  |
