Best TV Shows of 2005

> Switch to Advanced Search

Newly-Reviewed Programs
TV on DVD
All Shows: A-Z Index
Advanced Search

2008 Fall Season
2008 Summer Season
2007-08 Midseason
2007 Fall Season
2007 Summer Season
2006-07 Midseason
2006 Fall Season
2006 Summer Season
2005-06 Midseason
2005 Fall Season
Best Of 2007
Best Of 2006
Best Of 2005
How Metascores Are Calculated
Discuss TV In Our Forums

You Must Remember This: The Warner Bros. Story 73
PBS, 9/23

Easy Money 67
CW, Sunday

Valentine 47
CW, Sunday

The Ex List 62
CBS, Friday

Star Wars: The Clone Wars 64
Cartoon Network, Friday

Sanctuary 56
Sci-Fi, Friday

Friday Night Lights Season Three 78
101 (DirecTV), Wednesday

Pushing Daisies Season Two 82
ABC, Wednesday

Private Practice Season Two 44
ABc, Wednesday

Dirty Sexy Money Season Two 69
ABC, Wednesday

The IT Crowd 67
IFC, Tuesday

Chuck Season Two 74
NBC, Monday

Life Season Two 72
NBC, Monday, Friday

Dexter Season Three 78
Showtime, Sunday

Desperate Housewives Season Five 71
ABC, Sunday

Californication Season Two 62
Showtime, Sunday

Little Britain USA 61
HBO, Sunday

The Life & Times of Tim 57
HBO, Sunday

Grey's Anatomy Season Five 69
ABC, Thursday

Gary Unmarried 47
CBS, Wednesday

Knight Rider 21
NBC, Wednesday

The Mentalist 65
CBS, Tuesday

Opportunity Knocks 55
ABC, Tuesday

Worst Week 62
CBS, Monday

Heroes Season Three 58
NBC, Monday

It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia Season Four 70
FX, Thursday

House Season Five 77
Fox, Tuesday

Metacritic's complete Best of 2005 TV Coverage: Critic Top Ten Lists | Awards & Nominations

TV Critic Top Ten Lists

Unnumbered lists are sorted alphabetically by title.

Boston Globe (Matthew Gilbert)
1.	Lost (ABC)
2.	My Name Is Earl (NBC)
3.	The Comeback (HBO)
4.	Rome (HBO)
5.	Nip/Tuck (FX) and Rescue Me (FX)
6.	Six Feet Under (HBO) [series finale]
7.	House (Fox)
8.	Prison Break (Fox) and 24 (Fox) and Sleeper Cell (Showtime)
9.	The Closer (TNT)
10.	The West Wing (NBC)

Chicago Tribune (Maureen Ryan & Sid Smith)
	Battlestar Galactica (Sci-Fi)
	Deadwood (HBO)
	Everybody Hates Chris (UPN)
	Grey's Anatomy (ABC)
	House (Fox)
	Lost (ABC)
	My Name Is Earl (NBC)
	Rome (HBO)
	The Shield (FX)
	Veronica Mars (UPN)

Entertainment Weekly (Gillian Flynn)
1.	Arrested Development (Fox)
2.	Bodies (BBC America)
3.	Lost (ABC)
4.	The Staircase (Sundance)
5.	Entourage (HBO)
6.	Veronica Mars (UPN)
7.	(tie) Stella (Comedy Central) (tie) Wonder Showzen (MTV2)
8.	Real Sports With Bryant Gumbel (HBO)
9.	Everwood (WB)
10.	Prison Break (Fox)

Entertainment Weekly (Mark Harris)
1.	The West Wing (NBC)
2.	The Shield (FX)
3.	Rome (HBO)
4.	The Daily Show with Jon Stewart (Comedy Central)
5.	(tie) Unforgivable Blackness (PBS) (tie) No Direction Home: Bob Dylan (PBS)
6.	Entourage (HBO)
7.	Project Greenlight (Bravo)
8.	The Office (NBC)
9.	The Comeback (HBO)
10.	TV news' Hurricane Katrina coverage (various)

Kansas City Star / TVBarn.com (Aaron Barnhart)
1.	The Staircase (Sundance)
2.	Off To War (Discovery Times)
	30 Days (FX)
	The Boondocks (Cartoon Network)
	The Colbert Report (Comedy Central)
	Entourage (HBO)
	Foreign Exchange (PBS)
	The Girl In The Cafe (HBO)
	I’m Alan Partridge (BBC America)
	Intervention (A&E)
	Kitchen Confidential (Fox)
	The Shield (FX)

New York Daily News (David Bianculli)
	Arrested Development (Fox)
	Curb Your Enthusiasm (HBO)
	The Daily Show with Jon Stewart (Comedy Central) and Real Time With Bill Maher (HBO)
	Deadwood (HBO)
	Desperate Housewives (ABC)
	Lost (ABC)
	My Name Is Earl (NBC)
	No Direction Home: Bob Dylan (PBS)
	Over There (FX)
	Scrubs (NBC)

The New York Times (Alessandra Stanley)
1.	The Colbert Report (Comedy Central)
2.	Sleeper Cell (Showtime)
3.	Weeds (Showtime)
4.	House (Fox)
5.	TV news' Hurricane Katrina coverage (various)
6.	Grey's Anatomy (ABC)
7.	Commander In Chief (ABC)
8.	Law & Order: Criminal Intent (NBC)
9.	The Closer (TNT)
10.	Martha (syndicated)

Newsday (Diane Werts)
1.	Battlestar Galactica (Sci-Fi)
2.	House (Fox)
3.	My Name Is Earl (NBC)
4.	Everybody Hates Chris (UPN)
5.	Veronica Mars (UPN)
6.	Barbershop (Showtime)
7.	Slings & Arrows (Sundance)
8.	Sleeper Cell (Showtime)
9.	The Shield (FX)
10.	Lost (ABC)

People Weekly (Tom Gliatto)
1.	Lost (ABC)
2.	The Comeback (HBO)
3.	Prison Break (Fox)
4.	Everybody Hates Chris (UPN)
5.	Supernatural (WB)
6.	The Colbert Report (Comedy Central)
7.	Veronica Mars (UPN)
8.	Desperate Housewives (ABC)
9.	Dancing With The Stars (ABC)
10.	No Direction Home: Bob Dylan (PBS)

Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Rob Owen)
1.	Battlestar Galactica (Sci-Fi)
2.	Lost (ABC)
3.	Sleeper Cell (Showtime)
4.	Entourage (HBO)
5.	Arrested Development (Fox)
6.	The West Wing (NBC)
7.	The Office (NBC)
8.	My Name Is Earl (NBC)
9.	Veronica Mars (UPN)
10.	Over There (FX)

Pop Matters
1.	Arrested Development (Fox)
2.	Lost (ABC)
3.	House (Fox)
4.	The Simpsons (Fox)
5.	Veronica Mars (UPN)
6.	Nip/Tuck (FX)
7.	South Park (Comedy Central)
8.	The Daily Show With Jon Stewart (Comedy Central)
9.	24 (Fox)
10.	The Shield (FX)

San Francisco Chronicle (Tim Goodman)
1.	Arrested Development (Fox)
2.	My Name Is Earl (NBC)
3.	Rescue Me (FX)
4.	Rome (HBO)
5.	Entourage (HBO)
6.	Lost (ABC)
7.	Extras (HBO)
8.	Everybody Hates Chris (UPN)
9.	Family Guy (Fox)
10.	Over There (FX)

San Jose Mercury-News (Charlie McCollum)
1.	Lost (ABC)
2.	Various programs (FX)
3.	Deadwood (HBO)
4.	The Daily Show With Jon Stewart (Comedy Central) and The Colbert Report (Comedy Central)
5.	Veronica Mars (UPN)
6.	No Direction Home: Bob Dylan (PBS)
7.	Nightline (ABC)
8.	Various programs (BBC America)
9.	Grey's Anatomy (ABC)
10.	Arrested Development (Fox)

Time - Best New Shows (James Poniewozik)
1.	Battlestar Galactica (Sci-Fi)
2.	The Office (NBC)
3.	Weeds (Showtime)
4.	Sometimes In April (HBO)
5.	Project Runway (Bravo)
6.	Wonder Showzen (MTV2)
7.	The Colbert Report (Comedy Central)
8.	How I Met Your Mother (CBS)
9.	Prison Break (Fox)
10.	Everybody Hates Chris (UPN)

Time - Best Returning Shows (James Poniewozik)
1.	Lost (ABC)
2.	Deadwood (HBO)
3.	Arrested Development (Fox)
4.	Veronica Mars (UPN)
5.	Entourage (HBO)
6.	American Idol (Fox)
7.	Six Feet Under (HBO)
8.	Rescue Me (FX)
9.	The Shield (FX)
10.	South Park (Comedy Central)

USA Today (Robert Bianco)
1.	Lost (ABC)
2.	24 (Fox)
3.	House (Fox)
4.	Grey's Anatomy (ABC)
5.	Rescue Me (FX)
6.	Veronica Mars (UPN)
7.	My Name Is Earl (NBC)
8.	Arrested Development (Fox)
9.	CSI (CBS)
10.	Desperate Housewives (ABC)

Village Voice (Joy Press)
	Arrested Development (Fox)
	Deadwood (HBO)
	Green Wing (BBC America)
	Kath And Kim (Sundance)
	Lost (ABC)
	Rescue Me (FX)
	Rome (HBO)
	The Shield (FX)
	Veronica Mars (UPN)
	Weeds (Showtime)

Return to top of page