Metacritic Books

John James Audubon
by Richard Rhodes

ISBN: 0375414126
Alfred A. Knopf, 528 pages, $30.00
Nonfiction Biographies & Memoirs
Released 10/12/2004

From the Pulitzer Prize—winning historian Richard Rhodes, the first major biography of John James Audubon in forty years, and the first to illuminate fully the private and family life of the master illustrator of the natural world. [Knopf]

Overall Metascore

This is an average of all individual scores given by critics, on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (best).

87 / 100

Critic Reviews

Outstanding Booklist Donna Seaman
Full of passion and discovery, hardship and transcendence, Audubon's story is at once intimate and mythic, and Rhodes' fresh, comprehensive biography will capture the imagination of readers everywhere. [Aug 2004, p.1886]
Outstanding Boston Globe John Gregory Brown
A superb biography that shares its subject's abiding interest in precise and complete representation.
Outstanding Entertainment Weekly Wook Kim
Rhodes presents something more than a scrupulously researched portrait of a self-actualized genius: Through an understanding of the life and times of this flawed but likable character, we can trace the beginnings of our own complex national identity.
Outstanding Kirkus Reviews
Outstanding.
Outstanding Publishers Weekly
Rhodes succeeds in shedding light on how Audubon perfected his ability to capture in his depictions of birds so much life and emotion.
Outstanding San Francisco Chronicle Jesse Berrett
Rhodes' sentences are, to coin a term, Mississippian, flowing with an unhurried and irresistible majesty toward their goal. Without reaching for obscure words or overly complex formulations, his prose conveys thorough mastery of the subject, limitless curiosity and an enormous range of knowledge.
Outstanding The New York Times Book Review Jonathan Rosen
Rhodes...possesses tremendous technological and historical mastery, but it is his novelistic evocation, based on what feels a near complete identification with his subject, that gives his book its uplifting energy.
Outstanding Washington Post Kenn Kaufman
Literally hundreds of quotes, short and long, bring to life the voice of that era. Rhodes has given us the most three-dimensional portrait yet of Audubon the man.
Favorable The New Yorker
Rhodes occasionally lingers too long on his subject's publishing difficulties (a pet peeve of many authors), but he conveys both the singular glories of the early American wilderness -- sycamore tree crowded with nine thousand swallows -- and the solitary desperation of Audubon's labors.
Favorable The Economist
Richard Rhodes's account is the more detailed of the two, and shows more prints. He sets Audubon in the political context of the day.
Favorable Los Angeles Times Avedis Hadjian
Rhodes' book might have benefited from only a passing reference to the strains on Audubon's family life caused by his prolonged absences from home -- on expeditions or in Britain -- and from less extensive quotations of letter exchanges with his wife. [10 Oct 2004, p.R6]
Favorable Chicago Tribune Katrin Schultheiss
Rhodes clearly has not only enormous admiration but also a deep affection for Audubon. At times he seems almost reluctant to admit that Audubon ever behaved less than honorably. [17 Oct 2004, p.C1]
Unfavorable The New York Times Janet Maslin
Even when drawing dead subjects, Audubon infused his work with vigor and empathy, with a keen anthropomorphic vision of what these lives were like. His birds were wild. This book shouldn't be tame.

CLOSE THIS WINDOW

©2008 CNET Networks Inc. All rights reserved.