Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean (cube: 2004): Reviews

> Switch to Advanced Search

Games Homepage
Best of 2007 | 2006 |2005
Advanced Search

PS3 | PS2 | PS One | PSP

Xbox 360 | Xbox

Wii | DS | GBA | Cube | N64

PC | N-Gage | Dreamcast

How Metascores Are Calculated
Discuss Games In Our Forums

sort by name

sort by score

Stars indicate the most critically-acclaimed games.

Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean


8.7

based on 48 reviews
Read critic reviews
How did we calculate this?

based on 20 votes
Read user comments
Rate this game

Cheat Code Central

Embark upon an epic and emotional journey across a richly imagined world. Enjoy detailed character development and unravel an intricate plot spanning over 60 hours of gameplay. Innovative, dynamic "Magnus card" system unites all elements of gameplay. Capture the essence of items, weapons and spells in Magnus cards and use them for exploration and combat. Cards in your inventory change with the passage of time: food ripens or rots, blades rust and rare items increase in value. Baten Kaitos' unconventional card-based battle engine features over 1000 Magnus cardseach with unique artworkthat can be combined for a virtually infinite number of attacks and spell effects. [Namco]

PUBLISHER:	Namco
DEVELOPER:	Monolith Software
GENRE(S):	Role-Playing Game, Card Battle
PLAYERS:	1
ESRB RATING:	T (Teen)
RELEASE DATE:	November 16, 2004

All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...

Nintendojo

I’ve played through dozens upon dozens of games and I have never seen a game with graphics like this.

Nintendo Power

Making a strong case for my game of the year, BK's biggest strength is an amazing battle engine. [Jan 2004, p.135]

Game Chronicles

What makes it special are the breathtaking graphics, flawless character animation, great musical score, cool cut scenes, great story full of startling twists, and a unique card battle system that’s surprisingly fun.

NintendoWorldReport

This is first-class work with a compelling storyline and an active card-battle system that stays fresh throughout the life of the game.

Gaming Nexus

A beautifully crafted RPG that provides the boost that the GameCube so desperately needed.

Pelit (Finland)

A beautiful role-playing adventure with an above-average plot and some novel ideas. The otherwise interesting combat system relies a bit too much on luck, but overall Baten Kaitos is definitely one of GameCube's top adventures. [May. 05]

Games Radar UK (Pre-2006)

A beautiful and intense RPG, mixing turn-based strategy with graphics that, although pre-rendered, are mind blowing in terms of crispness, colour and detail. [GamesMaster]

Kombo

There is no reason why RPG lovers wouldn't like Baten Kaitos, but non-RPG lovers may have trouble adjusting to the slow speed of battles. Strategy lovers especially will appreciate the Magnus system's strategy.

IGN

The journey should last around 45 hours for the average gamer, but expect to spend some extra time if you want to unlock everything this game has to offer. Highly recommended.

Game Informer

Baten Kaitos is awesome. I was most surprised by how quickly this game drew me in, and it wasn't even the story that captured my interest - it was the setting. [Dec 2004, p.178]

TotalGames.net

Every single scene, be it a village, a forest clearing or an enormous city, is brimming with character and attention to detail.

My Gamer

Baten Kaitos has a couple main goals: to be beautiful technologically and to be a long adventure. Those goals are achieved with flying colors (literally).

GameSpot

The battle system has a flaw or two, but the lavishly detailed world of Baten Kaitos is a great place to go for a nice fairy tale.

GameZone

The card system is excellent. It has the random intensity and unpredictability of a real card game mixed with elements of real- and turn-based RPGs.

BonusStage

Part throwback to the good old days of Nintendo RPGs, part innovative gameplay, and all stylishly presented throughout the 50 or so hours you’ll get out of it.

Armchair Empire

The game’s soundtrack is honestly the best I’ve ever heard in any game that uses orchestrated music. The composition is sheer brilliance!

Gamers' Temple

A very, very solid RPG for the Cube. Don't let the card based battle system scare you off if you're not into that sort of thing. It's done very well and adds a nice change of pace from the normal RPGs.

GameBiz

The game fits on two discs, meaning it will take you at least 30 hours to beat, however they say it takes 60 hours, but we’re pretty sure that includes all the side quests.

Game Revolution

The unique combat is very addictive and a welcome aspect to the RPG genre. Some more innovative RPG elements and a few tweaks to the timing issue would turn this quirky gem into a very serious contender.

NTSC-uk

An enchanting tapestry of stylistic design, a deep and unconventional battle system, and fifty hours-plus of rewarding game play.

DailyGame

50+ hours to complete, need I say more?

WHAM! Gaming

Without giving too much away, I can say this: There is a plot-twist in this game that is so great that even the most hard-core RPG veterans won’t see it coming.

games(TM)

Having heard the energetic and emotional Japanese voice-over, the US equivalent is a huge letdown, being cheesy and devoid of any real emotion. This criticism aside, though, Baten Kaitos is a refreshing and sumptuous RPG. [Jan 2005, p.106]

Cheat Code Central

It's the balance of gameplay elements that make Baten Kaitos an interesting game to play. It's not particularly memorable but it does capture you in the moment. For a game of such length not to feel repetitive is truly an accomplishment.

Worth Playing

And this game somehow manages to have the least interesting story of the three aforementioned RPGs, which is a massive negative considering how vapid "Tales of Symphonia" and "Skies of Arcadia" were in that regard.

eToychest

The wonderful mechanics and aural and visual treats are simply not enough to lift this game above its own lackluster narrative.

GamePro

The greatest feature in Baten Kaitos may be the fact that you can fight and travel as freely as you like.

Yahoo! Games

Offers a lengthy adventure, a compelling, gorgeous world, and more than a dash of chaos to the order of conventional fantasy role-playing games.

DarkStation

What I like about the game is that it's simple but it's not overly simple, in that the game has a lot of different things going on in the background that you may not even notice.

1UP

It's a winning gamble with a new style of RPG combat, and it's pretty enough to frame and put on your wall in the bargain. With a stronger cast and narrative, though, it could have been an absolute world-beater.

EuroGamer

While the story and characters are unfortunately very weak, Baten Kaitos is easy to recommend to anyone looking for an RPG that focuses strongly on gameplay rather than storytelling.

Pelaaja (Finland)

Baten Kaitos is again a proof that on the GameCube rpg-front, it’s quality over quantity. Even the horrible voice acting cannot hold back down this grand epic. [May 2005, p.91]

Next Level Gaming

High production values, a unique card system and beautiful artistry give the game just enough to make it stand out on it’s own.

Gamestyle

When all is said and done, Baten Kaitos does have the substance to back up its style.

Just RPG

Baten Kaitos has more than just a story. It features a strangely intuitive battle system built around decks of cards called Magnus.

RPG Fan

It’s very unfortunate that everything in Baten Kaitos did not come together to create a truly great gaming experience. The shallow battle system becomes boring quickly, and the voice acting’s poor quality drops the game to a simply average level.

Weekly Famitsu

8 / 8 / 8 / 7 - 31 silver [Vol 782]

Detroit Free Press

The storyline is lame. Nevertheless, we enjoyed the unusual blend of gaming challenges pulled together in this other-worldly adventure.

Warcry

Though it might not be real-time combat, the card battle system works well and does give combat a fast pace. The only real problem is the lack of good cut scenes.

Electronic Gaming Monthly

If graphics and gameplay are more important to you than story, by all means dive in. [Holiday 2004, p.134]

GameSpy

The brisk card battles provide a frantic element few RPGs can claim, and the visuals hold up their end of the bargain. But a huge reliance on luck, some quirky gameplay issues, and a ho-hum plot saddled with atrocious voice acting holds this one down like a pair of concrete shoes.

The New York Times

While the game doesn't have a compelling story or interesting characters, it does have an easygoing charm and a few goofy locales like a village built from candy and an ingenious hall of mirrors.

Edge Magazine

So well integrated is the card collection/reward mechanic that the traditional RPG exploration elements slip easily between the staccato rhythm of the battles. For this reason, the game takes on an invigorating freshness that overrides most of its generic frustrations. [Jan 2005, p.93]

Sydney Morning Herald

Floating island environments are intricate and beautiful but paper-thin characters and an evil empire revenge yarn are disappointingly dull.

Play Magazine

Baten Kaitos isn't bad, but it doesn't stack up to the games it seemingly wants to emulate. [Dec 2004, p.58]

GMR Magazine

Unfortunately, unique visuals and a well-made battle system can't always rescue this easy linear game from the swell of mediocrity that often threatens to overrun it. [Jan 2005, p.82]

G4 TV

An engaging card battle game wrapped up in a solidly mediocre story.

Nintendophiles

The fact that it was a card battle game, it could only hold attention for so long to where the system got repetitive, and fighting was a drag after the halfway point.

The average user rating for this game is 8.7 (out of 10) based on 20 User Votes
Note: User votes are NOT included in the Metascore calculation.

Katie H. gave it a9:
The only bad thing about this game are the VOICE ACTORS. Oh my god, it sounds like it was recorded in a toilet bowl.

Krystal B. gave it an8:
A delightfully epic and original game, though perhaps at times more original than actually good. Overall, though, definitely a must-play.

Carl C. gave it a10:
Near perfect. Best RPG I've ever played.

[Anonymous] gave it an8:
Is this game a masterpiece? No, but it's still a pretty fun and decent RPG. IT kind of has a weird storyline that's really odd compared to others; most people will dislike it, and the voice acting is horrible (it's the worst thing about this game) not to mention the poor acting makes the characters seem even worse. the creators said that the protagonist would be very different from others. [***SPOILERS***] He seemd rather careless, and was actually really nice to other people when they needed help, and in one part of the game, he turned evil...but not badass. But then again, this game features an innovative new card-based system. Some people found it repetitive and boring, but I felt that defeating new enemies and getting new cards made the system more fun and compelling. It gets a little boring after hours of play...but not minutes. those who say it's boring are probably just the hardcore gamers who only play FPS's. Sure, they're fun, but RPG's are just plain better. the graphics remind me of Final Fantasy VII, which had great prerendered backgrounds, and sloppy polygonal characters. BK had even more beautifully polished backgrounds (the clouds look absolutely amazing) and the characters aren't so bad, either. The game is very long (took me 55 hours to beat, yet it will be 60+ for more casual gamers) with many enemies, levels, and over 1000 cards. If you can ignore the bad acting, try out this game. It's a good RPG.

Yuki S. gave it a10:
Baten Kaitos is an amazing rpg game that I became obsessed with the moment I watched the intro. The score is amazing and vibrant, ranging from slow classical to speedy almost rock. The graphics are spectacular, and the charactor development takes you in to the game. I admit to throwing pillows at the t.v. when a particurally annoying scene came. The card-style fighting system is challenging (I still haven't gotton the combo system thing down yet). What really pulled me into the game were the graphics and the settings. The intro is amazing, and really gives you a taste for what's to come. I recommend it to anyone who loves rpg's, and to everyone who isn't a big fan, either.

The Elusive Possom gave it an8:
Baten Kaitos gets a lot of things right: the soundtrack is brilliant, for starters, being a delicious mix of orchestral splendour and power metal. The pre-rendered backgrounds look great, and the character models suit them well. The battle system is certainly inventive and easy to get into, although perhaps unnecessarily involved (I've almost finished the game, and I haven't paid any attention to the run/pairs combo system). The storyline is pretty well thought out and movement not as linear as some other RPGs. However, the voice-acting is unfortunately dire, but this can be turned off. Also, if you're the kind of person who wants to find everything in a game, then be prepared to take a LOT of pictures early on with the camera Magnus, because you'll kick yourself when you lack the essence of the first boss you faced.

Austin R. gave it a10:
I loved it....the graphics were amazing,and the gameplay was great......I LOVE THIS RPG!!!!